Some massive galaxies in the early universe stopped forming stars, and astronomers have struggled to explain why. A leading idea blames the supermassive black hole at a galaxy's center. When it is actively feeding, it can drive powerful winds that clear out the cold gas new stars are made from. The idea is widely accepted, but direct evidence for it has been hard to find.

A new review by Rebecca Davies of Swinburne and Sirio Belli of the University of Bologna argues that the James Webb Space Telescope is starting to supply that evidence. The paper, "Galactic Outflows and Star-Formation Quenching: A JWST Perspective", was posted to arXiv on October 13, 2026, and revised on October 18. Universe Today reported on it November 17. The review finds that gas outflows are common in massive galaxies at "cosmic noon." It also finds that the outflows linked to galaxies shutting down usually trace back to the central black hole.

The era in question

Cosmic noon refers to roughly 8 to 12 billion years ago, when star formation across the universe was at its peak. In redshift terms, the review focuses on galaxies around z~2. That is a good place to look for quenching, the process that shuts down star formation. During this period, the number of stars forming per unit volume of the universe reached its peak, and some of the most massive galaxies were also starting to stop.

For each galaxy, the researchers wanted two kinds of information. The first is its star formation history: whether it is still making stars, has recently stopped, or has been quiet for a long time. The second is whether gas is currently leaving it. JWST spectroscopy provides both.

How you see a wind from 10 billion light-years away

The team used separate spectral signatures for each question. They traced star formation histories through Balmer absorption features in the galaxies' starlight. They traced outflowing gas with the sodium doublet known as NaID. Cool, neutral gas absorbs light at these wavelengths. When that absorption is blueshifted, the gas is moving toward the observer, out of the galaxy and in front of its stars.

Davies summarized the approach in plain terms to Universe Today. Winds from active galactic nuclei (AGN) blow gas out of galaxies, and JWST can now measure how much cold gas is being ejected.

This review builds on earlier work from the Blue Jay survey, described in a 2024 paper led by Davies. That study used JWST's NIRSpec instrument to collect spectra of 113 galaxies between redshifts 1.7 and 3.5. It found excess NaID absorption in 46 percent of the massive galaxies. Half of those absorption profiles were blueshifted by at least 100 kilometers per second.

What the numbers say

The 2026 review pulls the results together. Neutral gas outflows show up in roughly 25 to 50 percent of massive galaxies, meaning those with stellar masses above about 1010 solar masses. That fraction does not depend on a galaxy's star formation rate. Outflows appear about as often in galaxies that are busily forming stars as in those that have gone quiet.

Advertisement

What differs is the likely power source:

  • In star-forming galaxies, the outflows could be driven by star formation, by an AGN, or by both.
  • In quiescent galaxies, which have stopped forming stars, the outflows are generally attributed to current or past AGN activity.

The Blue Jay paper put numbers on the scale of these winds. It estimated mass outflow rates of 3 to 100 solar masses per year. In galaxies that are actively quenching, the mass loading factors were between 4 and 360. The mass loading factor compares the rate gas leaves a galaxy to the rate it forms stars. A value of 360 means the galaxy is losing gas hundreds of times faster than it turns gas into stars. The energy and momentum carried by these flows also exceed the expected injection rates from supernova explosions, which suggests those galaxies could be caught in a rapid blowout phase powered by the AGN.

Belli told Universe Today that the outflows turned out to be more common and more powerful than astronomers had expected.

Advertisement

Winds that regulate, and winds that end it

The finding comes with an important caveat. Most galaxies with outflows are not quenching. According to the researchers, in most cases the winds act as a regulator. They remove some gas and keep the galaxy in a kind of equilibrium, but they do not shut down star formation.

That makes the picture more interesting than "black hole switches galaxy off." Outflows appear to be a normal part of how massive galaxies at this epoch work. Only the most powerful ones appear able to quench a galaxy. What triggers those extreme cases is still an open question. Davies names galaxy mergers and radio jets as possible triggers.

Belli also offered a closer-to-home reason the question matters. If the Milky Way had been quenched at cosmic noon, it would likely not have formed many new stars in the last 10 billion years, and the Solar System, which is about 5 billion years old, would not exist.

Why It Matters

AGN-driven outflows are widely considered a key way to regulate and quench star formation in massive galaxies. As the review acknowledges, though, direct observational evidence linking outflows to quenching has remained elusive for decades.

JWST changes that in two ways. It can measure a galaxy's star formation history and its outflows in the same spectrum at cosmic noon, so researchers can compare the two directly. It can also detect neutral gas in absorption, which tracks the cold material that would otherwise become stars. In the Blue Jay sample of quenching galaxies, the measured outflow energies exceed what supernovae are expected to supply. The review also reports growing evidence that recent rapid quenching is associated with powerful AGN-driven outflows. That strengthens the black hole case, though the review notes other mechanisms, such as AGN heating, are probably needed to keep galaxies quenched over long timescales.

The work also leaves open questions. If a quarter to half of massive galaxies have outflows but most keep forming stars, then having an outflow is not the deciding factor. Something else must determine which winds become strong enough to shut a galaxy down. Davies points to mergers and radio jets as candidates, but those remain hypotheses for now.

Sources