Some of the best samples from the outer solar system don't come back on a spacecraft. They drift down through Earth's upper atmosphere, and high-altitude NASA aircraft pick them up in the stratosphere. According to a new paper in Science Advances, twelve of these interplanetary dust particles hold a chemical record of water that reacted with rock somewhere beyond Neptune. That water is unusually rich in the heavy isotopes of oxygen.

The study was led by Lindsay Keller of NASA's Johnson Space Center, working with researchers at UCLA. It addresses a question that has been open for more than a decade: why does the Sun's oxygen look so different from the oxygen in the rocky planets?

A mismatch the Sun left behind

Oxygen comes in three stable isotopes. Oxygen-16 is by far the most common. Oxygen-17 and oxygen-18 carry one and two extra neutrons, and those are what "heavy" refers to here. In 2011, results from NASA's Genesis mission showed that the Sun is rich in oxygen-16 compared with Earth, Mars and the asteroids, which all carry proportionally more of the heavy isotopes.

That is a strange result. The Sun and the planets formed from the same cloud of gas and dust, so in principle they should share an isotopic signature. Something must have pulled heavy oxygen out of the solar mix and delivered it to the solid material that built the planets.

The leading explanation is carbon monoxide self-shielding, a process thought to have operated about 4.5 billion years ago. The idea is that ultraviolet light breaks apart carbon monoxide molecules in the outer parts of the young solar nebula. The common oxygen-16 form of CO is abundant enough to block the light that would destroy it. The rarer forms carrying oxygen-17 and oxygen-18 get no such protection, so they break apart more readily. The freed heavy oxygen atoms can then end up in water ice. If that happened, there should be a reservoir of water enriched in heavy oxygen somewhere in the cold outer solar system. Finding a sample of it has been the difficult part.

Why comet missions didn't settle it

The obvious place to look is comets, and spacecraft have sampled them. But Universe Today notes that the material gathered by missions such as Stardust and Rosetta was melted in the process, which destroyed the water-bearing minerals that would preserve the original isotopic record.

Interplanetary dust particles get around this almost by accident. The grains are small enough to survive entry into Earth's atmosphere without melting, according to The Brighter Side of News. High-altitude aircraft collect them in the stratosphere, where NASA regularly gathers interplanetary dust, so the water-bearing minerals inside them can still be studied.

Clay minerals that remember

The twelve grains in the study contain clay minerals, which form when liquid water reacts with rock. The clays lock in the oxygen isotope ratios of the water that made them. In these particles, that water was enriched in oxygen-17 and oxygen-18, which is the signature CO self-shielding predicts for outer-solar-system ice.

Advertisement

Isotopes alone would not tell the team where the grains came from. Hydrated dust particles have been studied for years, and earlier work tended to treat them as mostly asteroidal. A NASA technical report by Snead, Keller, McKeegan and Messenger, which made precision oxygen isotope measurements of hydrated particles at UCLA, describes that earlier view. If these grains came from the asteroid belt, the heavy-water story would mean something quite different.

Radiation tracks as a travel log

The team used radiation damage to work out where the grains came from. While a dust grain drifts through interplanetary space, energetic particles from the Sun leave microscopic tracks in its minerals. The longer the exposure, the more tracks build up.

Advertisement

According to Universe Today, earlier studies showed that grains from the Kuiper Belt carry roughly a hundred times more of these tracks than particles from asteroids, because of their much longer time in interplanetary space. The Brighter Side of News adds that earlier calibration work by Keller and George Flynn found some grains collected at Earth with exposure ages above a million years, too long to fit journeys from the main asteroid belt or from Jupiter-family comets. Their track densities were consistent with an origin farther out, in the Kuiper Belt, the region of icy bodies beyond Neptune. The tracks work more like a measure of travel time than a return address: they narrow down where the grains likely came from without tying them to a particular object.

Taken together, the evidence points one way. The clays formed when water reacted with rock on Kuiper Belt objects. That water carried a heavy-oxygen excess of the kind CO self-shielding predicts. And the grains then spent a very long time drifting inward before being caught in Earth's stratosphere.

Why It Matters

The result offers physical evidence of the reservoir that the leading explanation for the Genesis oxygen mismatch requires. The NASA technical report notes that material representing the oxygen-17 and oxygen-18 rich end-member has been rare. These twelve grains appear to preserve a chemical record of it, although the Brighter Side of News cautions that the grains' chemistry alone cannot establish exactly where or when the isotope separation took place.

The findings also suggest that water in the outer solar system stayed largely isolated from inner solar system material. That matters for any account of how water was distributed through the early solar system. Universe Today reports that the authors point to Saturn, whose growing gravity may have created a barrier in the protoplanetary disk that kept material from the outer solar system from moving inward. The Brighter Side of News notes that the authors also discuss growing giant planets slowing the inward movement of dust and ice in general.

There is also a methodological point. As the melted comet material showed, sample-return missions are not always gentle with their samples. Dust collected in the stratosphere, at the right size, arrives intact, and can be examined with laboratory instruments that are impractical to fly. The trade-off is that a grain's origin has to be reconstructed after collection, and in this study the radiation-track analysis did that.

Twelve particles is a small sample, and the work rests on combining isotopic and exposure evidence rather than on any single direct measurement of origin. Still, the result shifts at least some hydrated dust particles from the asteroid category to the Kuiper Belt one, and it supports a chemical process that may help explain why the Sun and the planets differ in their oxygen. The Brighter Side of News notes that the overall size and distribution of the reservoir remain unknown, and that more grains will be needed to tell whether the signature is common across Kuiper Belt bodies.

Sources