Most papers that put Newton and Einstein in the same sentence promise something big. This one is mostly a warning about how you could fool yourself.

Muhittin Eser is a mathematician in the Department of Mathematics and Computer Science at Freie Universität Berlin. In a paper published in The Astrophysical Journal on November 5, 2026, he takes the classical model of the Moon's tides on Earth and adds a term for the cross polarization of a gravitational wave. The idea is to see where a small relativistic signal might sit inside a system people have studied for centuries. Then he asks a harder question: could anyone ever tell that signal apart from ordinary mistakes in the model?

"We are not claiming to have discovered a new gravitational effect," Eser said in the university's announcement. "What we show is how one could look for it in a targeted way."

Two old theories, one model

Universe Today puts the work in historical terms. Tidal theory goes back to Newton's Principia in 1687. Gravitational waves are a prediction of general relativity. Detectors have now recorded thousands of gravitational-wave events, most of them from merging black holes or neutron stars. Eser's paper is an attempt to write both pieces of physics into a single model of the Moon's pull on Earth, which could open another way to test gravity.

In practice, the Moon and Sun pull on the oceans and the solid Earth, and both deform in response; those movements can be recorded with high-precision instruments and calculated very accurately with Newtonian gravity. Eser adds a component tied to the cross polarization of a gravitational wave. Such a component would show up as an off-diagonal residual in the tidal signal, separate from the standard Newtonian pattern. The paper's title, "Frame Degeneracy and Sine-Quadrature Residuals in Lunar Tidal Modeling," names both the signal shape he is looking for and the main obstacle to finding it.

The trouble with frames

That obstacle is degeneracy. According to the abstract of the paper's preprint, lunar-frame errors generate responses indistinguishable from the cross-residual signal. If your assumed orientation or position of the Moon is slightly off, the error can leave the same fingerprint in the data as the relativistic term you are hunting for.

The FU Berlin release lists three things that get in the way: the choice of reference frame, uncertainty in the positions of Earth and Moon, and systematic measurement errors. Any of them could produce a residual that has nothing to do with gravitational waves.

The paper states the consequence directly. Because some frame errors cannot be separated from the signal, any finite constraint on the cross term is "intrinsically prior limited." The abstract says the physical contribution includes establishing what independent constraints are required to distinguish a cross-residual from standard tidal-model errors, which means the frame and the ephemeris (the table of where the bodies are) have to be pinned down by other means.

What the forecasts say

To make this concrete, Eser runs what the abstract calls a joint-prior GLS/Fisher forecast. It is a generalized-least-squares analysis combined with a Fisher-matrix estimate of how precisely parameters could be measured, with prior knowledge of frame, ephemeris, instrumental and other uncertainties built in. He applies it to three synthetic gravimeter networks, labeled conservative, moderate and optimistic.

Advertisement

The figure reported for each network is the uncertainty along the worst principal axis, the direction in parameter space that the data constrain least:

  • Conservative network: 9.513 × 10-3
  • Moderate network: 4.490 × 10-4
  • Optimistic network: 4.182 × 10-5

From the conservative to the optimistic case, the worst-axis uncertainty shrinks by more than two orders of magnitude. That shows how much the result depends on how good the measurement network is assumed to be.

The Monte Carlo section is the most useful part of the paper. Eser ran Monte Carlo injection-recovery experiments to check whether the standard error bars hold up in practice. Under the abstract's declared stress budget, the optimistic network's formal coverage fell to 0.317. Put simply, the stated error bars contained the true value about a third of the time, when they are supposed to contain it far more often. The false-positive rate came out at 0.685, so in the simulation an analysis that trusted those error bars would flag a nonexistent signal more often than not.

Advertisement

A calibrated robust covariance, a more careful treatment of the error structure, fixed this in the simulations. Held-out coverage rose to 0.949 and the false-positive rate fell to 0.051, close to what a well-behaved statistical test should give.

The lesson is that the scenario with the tightest error bars is also the one most likely to produce a false detection if the errors are handled carelessly. Better data on its own does not prevent mistakes. It can make them more convincing.

Why It Matters

So far, gravitational waves have mostly been studied through large cosmic events such as mergers of black holes or neutron stars. Eser's approach looks instead for tiny signatures in our immediate astronomical neighborhood, using something familiar, the Moon's tides, which can already be described and measured very precisely. The FU Berlin release says future searches could draw on high-precision gravity and tide measurements, geodesy and lunar laser ranging. In lunar laser ranging, laser pulses are sent to reflectors on the Moon to measure the Earth-Moon distance very precisely, which may be relevant to the frame and position problems the paper identifies as the main limit.

Equally important is what the paper leaves out. The abstract says plainly that no detection or constraint is claimed, and that the results remain conditional on the synthetic assumptions behind the simulated networks. This is a methods paper. It lays out where a signal would appear, what could imitate it, and how badly a naive analysis could go wrong.

That has practical value. Someone will eventually look for small anomalies in tidal or gravity records and be tempted to call them new physics. This paper gives them a checklist first: pin down the frame, pin down the ephemeris, calibrate the covariance, and only then interpret the residual. The 0.685 false-positive rate shows what happens if those steps are skipped.

Whether Einstein turns up in the tides is still open. Eser has worked out how much has to go right before anyone could say so.

Sources